Thursday, March 08, 2018

The Devastating Hunt, Episode V

My son likes to play an online interactive video game called "Fortnite." It involves landing on an island that has a gradually shrinking engagement range, and strategically fighting to be the last man standing after blowing away all the others on the island. It is interesting because unlike most other games of this sort, if you die, you die, and you're out, period, thuh end, you're done. You don't just hop right back up again and keep playing, you must start all over in a brand new game.

I bring this up for a couple reasons. One, the fact that you die die DIE is one of the genuine appeals to the game. The fight itself is much more meaningful because there is so much on the line. The fact that the Chiefs have died died DIED so often right when they get into the postseason means it is that much more meaningful when we win. We've won one playoff game since 1994, that against the Texans after the 2015 season, and it was memorably exhilarating. Yeah, that was it, and while anyone could've beaten the Texans that day the fact is it was really really fun. Sure the Patriots have around 8,000 playoff wins in that same time period, but how fun was any given one of those? Don't get me wrong, I'd trade the Patriots success for the Chiefs any day, but still.

The other reason is that recently after my son had in succession a good Fortnite win then a tough loss, he asked me, "Dad, do you know what my favorite Fortnite win is? The next one. That's what we all tell each other at school." This sentiment struck me, it is much like one that has always resonated with me from a fine collegiate softball player from a few years ago, Michelle Granger, who when asked if she actually does enjoy the game replied, "It is fun while you're in it." What a simple yet extremely wise statement. Enjoy the game, but when it is done move on with the next game and other things in life.

I share this because I've spent a lot of blog space analyzing the current Chiefs situation in light of the fact that I am doing what could be considered the most ferocious naval-lint-extraction about what it could possibly be that's afflicting the Chiefs so gruesomely when it comes to trying to win a playoff game. I do this a lot for the therapy -- I've said this a number of times before, but it is true -- it is just a way to process it all. More on that later.

I also share it because it may be reasonably broached: "Why do you spend so much energy going over all this past stuff? Let's move on with what we've got and hope for the best -- it actually looks pretty good right now! What's done is done -- just like the Fortnite players say, 'The best Chiefs game ever is the next win!'" Please, don't misunderstand me -- I got you. I'm with you. I do understand. I do have extraordinarily high hopes for our team. I really actually truly do.

And I will go over some of the things that comprise Chiefs greatness, I will, with the sincerely earnest enthusiasm about our future chances, seriously. I will get to that, even a bit of it in this very post.

But I also do all of this because I have this idea, yeah, maybe it is a totally misled wayward ridiculous idea, that identifying the insane things that have afflicted the Chiefs in the past may be judiciously addressed -- my last blog post went into great detail about the specific and identifiable ways the NFL itself does indeed put the hurt on the Chiefs. Yes, maybe there is nothing that can be done about any of that. Okay...

But I'm still going to call it out. We should know about it. We should be poised to even say something about it. We should hope to see things made right. Even if nothing gets done about it we can have a stronger affection for this thing The Kansas City Chiefs, being able to appreciate the genuinely endearing things about it in spite of those unjust assaults.

And yes, I do believe one of those debilitating things is Hunt. Again, it isn't Clark or Lamar or any of what they've been about per se. Lamar was a giant in the illustrious legacy of pro football and Clark has done his difficult work above board with the Chiefs first and foremost in his heart.

As I think about the past injustices from the NFL itself, I couldn't help but think about Lamar's history with it from day one. I wondered about Hunt originating from the simple and very gracious request Lamar made to the NFL when he asked to add his team to the league. The league said "F*** off" and Lamar went and started the AFL. If you've read the history you should know.

The NFL was a major league aye-hole about the whole thing.

They really couldn't stand Lamar Hunt.

Lamar persevered. He vigorously encouraged the other owners to hold on when the AFL floundered in its early years. He introduced a number of splendid innovations to make the AFL more exciting without affecting the purity of the pro football game. He even went out of his way to abandon his beloved Dallas and move his team to Kansas City in extremely gracious deference to the NFL when it deliberately tried to undermine his efforts by putting the Cowboys franchise there right after Hunt had earlier asked to have his team there!

What was it about all of this that formed this thing Hunt? Was Lamar far too conciliatory? Yes there were a lot of other things in the mix, but Lamar's AFL enterprise in and of itself was not one of them no matter what the NFL thought about it. Was the NFL even more resentful that they were pressured into the merger? How much animosity did Tex Schramm have towards Lamar when they secretly met in a car on that airport parking lot to begin arranging the merger? I honestly believe Schramm was respectful of Hunt and all the two parties wanted to accomplish.

What was it that moved the NFL to bend? I wonder if it wasn't as much Lamar as it was someone else with the ganas to make it happen. I'm loathe to admit it but I think the seminal point in the AFL's gravitas -- and ironically in the perpetuation of Hunt -- came in the brief tenure of AFL Commissioner ::gulp:: the Raiders Al Davis.

Al Davis (on the right) pictured with 
Bills owner Ralph Wilson
At a time when the AFL needed a "got-it" guy, Al Davis was that man, charged with the responsibility of going to the mat bruised and bloodied if need be. Davis relished the challenge, and did phenomenally well, urging the AFL to be much braver about getting the best players from the NFL. It was at that time when the New York Giants stole away a Buffalo Bills kicker that Davis knew, it's on.

The tricky thing about all this was that while Davis wanted the AFL to go its own way, Hunt, Schramm, and the NFL were working out a deal behind his back. Davis was livid, but really, Davis was legitimately called on to take one for the AFL so it could have the leverage it needed to make the merger deal. In that sense, Davis sacrificed himself and his terrific leadership skills for the good of the entire pro football world, and I can't believe he wasn't aware of the value of that contribution.

(As a side note, the NFL's commissioner, Pete Rozelle, simply took over the AFL after the merger fundamentals were hammered out. For an AFL purist like Davis -- bless his heart -- it was not surprising he was constantly embroiled in conflict with Rozelle throughout the next couple of decades. The Raiders and the NFL themselves did not have the most wholesomely amicable relationship, to say the least.)

Davis was the guy with the got-it. Over the 16 years following his brief stint as pro football's game-changer, his got-it put the Raiders into four Super Bowls -- they won three of them. Davis was one of the best managers of a pro football franchise ever, deftly putting lots of players with got-it on the football field. In the early 1990's when he started making it about himself, almost to a pathological degree, he lost his "got-it" touch, and the Raiders suffered (I'd say there are a few Chiefs fans who aren't complaining a whole lot about that).

The AFL benefited from Davis' efforts tremendously, and Lamar, well, didn't. The Chiefs didn't. Yes the Chiefs won a Super Bowl shortly after that, and yes Lamar arranged the merger and did a dozen other magnificent things for pro football, but it just wasn't the same as what Al did -- as much as it pains me to say that. And to that extent, how much of all this turned itself into Hunt?...

I've only shared much of the surface stuff that may reveal things about it all, but I'm always wondering what is much deeper. I've tried to delve there but I confess I'm not the most intrepid investigative reporter in all this -- I have neither the time nor the wherewithal. As I've said there is much I don't know, and I want to presume nothing. I only want to sincerely confront that which is true. I'm also encountering 97% of Chiefs fans who insist, "Fugheddaboudit, let it go. We've lost games only because of bad bounces." I understand that.

I still can't help but think. What if I did go deep? What if I did ask around -- are there any people somewhere somewhat in the organization, in the arena -- perceptive, insightful, authentic, observant, holding the truth about things in the highest regard and eminently respected for it. Those who see this, who'd talk about it articulately, meaningfully...

I've thought about this kind of thing before, written about it in this blog: What would we find out if we asked the playoff opponent players about what it was like playing really good Chiefs teams and the beating them? There are so many of them. What would they tell us about what they saw in the Chiefs, what happened with the Chiefs on the field that was just not like it was during the regular season?

What would we find out? What would we find out if we heard from those who know about Hunt?

Could it be nothing much? Yeah, maybe.

I just don't think so, however. I think there's something.

So what does it take to overcome Hunt?

Much of it means addressing all the things I've talked about already, especially that stuff with the NFL. With that in mind I'd like to add another thing I'd do as commissioner, something I hadn't thought about adding, but now I think is just as important. Related to it is a key component of Chiefs success, one which gives great meaning to the whole "The best Chiefs game ever is the next win" attitude.

First, that important NFL dynamic I would comprehensively address as commissioner:

- Radically modify what happens with free agency. I have been reluctant to bring up the whole free agency thing because for one, I am fully on board with players making as much money as they can. I share this disclaimer because for years I have raged against what free agency does to competitive integrity. It may then seem I'm against the players, but I am not.

I am only against what these kinds of things do to my team.

I've also held back because -- at least from what we see on the surface -- the NFL actually works to be fair and above board with the draft and strict rules about player movement. It is far better than what major league baseball allows, which results in teams like the Yankees and Dodgers having far more success than the other teams. (Don't think the Yankees and Dodgers have had far more success than other teams in light of the fact neither team has appeared in many World Series recently? Just look at the number of winning seasons or instances they've qualified for postseason play over the past several years. They far outdistance any other major league team.)

Yes, some will revile parity and enthusiastically appreciate when these kinds of teams experience much more success -- it is indeed no different than favoring a New York-New England Super Bowl matchup happening more often than not. As I shared in my last blog post, this philosophy is a slap in the face of every other team's fans. And yes, far too many people have this "larger market team success is best" mentality, especially powerful people who are always seeking ways to make it more likely to happen.

Thing is, the NFL does do a decent job of at least working to make sure every team has equal footing, and I genuinely appreciate that. They've also done a number of things to mitigate the debilitating impact of free agency on teams like the Chiefs -- offered compensatory picks, allowed franchise tags -- I think the NBA has something called a "mid-level exception," I don't know if the NFL does -- any of a number of rules and restrictions related to how teams may use free agency to take advantage of their large market status.

What I don't like is the salary cap. It isn't as much that it limits what players may earn -- as I've said it is no big deal to me that players make millions, that's cool. The problem is the cap hampers teams particularly when they want to retain their own fine players.

This is why if I had my way, I'd get rid of free agency all together. After a player is drafted by a team and the team spends a gob of time and energy developing him, they should be able to keep him if they want -- and pay him as much as he should get. I know some will say this "reserve clause" makes it so teams won't pay them, but a natural monopsony model where the teams and the union together work out salaries for players on whichever team they are on goes a long way to solving this.

This then means the teams that do the best drafting and developing will be the most successful -- and this is the way it should be. Who cares if a given team is full of superstars getting paid a lot of money simply because the team did a fine job of drafting and developing them? I agree there'd have to be certain rules and restrictions in place so teams don't take advantage of this, such as a team preventing a fine player from being on the field when he could be with another team out there showing his abilities -- I'm great with those kinds of things.

Bottom line here? Before the last season why did the Chiefs have to choose between Dontari Poe and Eric Berry? Why? It was only about the money. We drafted both, we developed both, we committed to both, why couldn't the Chiefs just pay both? We let Poe go and to replace him we picked up Bennie Logan as a free agent. Good try, but I'm sorry, Dontari was way better.

We just watched Marcus Peters get dealt away -- for several reasons but what was one of the most prominent ones? It was that in a couple years Peters was likely to ask for $20 million a year and we didn't want to mess with that. Let's get something for him now was the thinking. Why? Why can't we pay him? He is indeed one of the most talented and fiercely competitive players in the league, and we got squat for him much because of this salary cap crap.

There are other examples of the decisions the Chiefs have to make simply because of the money -- simply because we must "manage the cap." That stinks.

Why does any team have to get rid of its good players under these conditions? I do believe much of it comes from this benighted idea: Should a team like the Chiefs become dominant it simply would not be good for the NFL. The Chiefs would be getting all that money to pay all its terrific players from the broadcasting contracts of the media world led by execs always hoping for much more success from the New Yorks and Los Angeleses and Chicagos. What? they'd cry, All that money going to the Chiefs? Look at that, what a revenue-stream KILLER: that podunk Midwest town's team has just appeared in four straight Super Bowls! What's with that?

So in a very real sense, this thing parity is sustained not as much to make sure the small market Chiefs have a little boost and can at least compete a little, but to make sure a phenomenally good Chiefs team doesn't keep a Patriots or Giants or Rams or Cowboys from appearing in Super Bowls often enough.

Yeah, more complicity even in the apparent "fairness" of it all.

Okay, I know, this is what we've got. Moaning and groaning about it won't change that. Deal with it. The Chiefs have a challenge, greater than many other teams. So what must happen in this environment? What do you need to navigate through it?

You need a skilled navigator.

This then is the transition into one of the most critical elements to overcoming Hunt. Yes there are a lot of factors involved in this, but this is one of the most important. You can say it in two words.

Brett Veach.

Over the past few years I raved about the work that John Dorsey had done in drafting and assembling the present Chiefs team, which is indeed actually looking pretty good. Clark summarily fired him just before the season started last year, stunning us all. He then elevated Veach to GM and we all wondered, hmm, how will he do?

We're finding out that Veach has a wealth of football experience under his belt, being with Andy Reid for years, cutting his teeth with John Dorsey. It's fun to watch him work right now, watch him take advantage of the opportunity -- and so far he's been looking pretty good. He's been boldly moving on important matters, taking care of business -- unloading Peters (controversial move), dealing Alex Smith (outstanding move), and doing everything he can with little room under that abhorrent cap as well as within the confines of the NFL's soft disdain for his small market Chiefs.

The most important factor of all, and we just have to see...

Does Brett have enough got-it to translate into Chiefs postseason wins?

Really, let's cut to the chase. Will Brett bring those things to the football field that overcome Hunt? I know it is a tall order. There are certainly a dozen other things Brett is doing as a high-energy very youthful GM. That may seem like a liability, having little experience, but again he does have the experience. There must be a reason a 39 year-old is our GM.

I'd like to think his got-it becomes Chiefs got-it.

We will definitely need a lot of it to get going on richly enjoying some magnificently delightful postseason winning.
___

(Episode VI)
___

Thursday, March 01, 2018

The Devastating Hunt, Episode IV

Clark Hunt definitely doesn't like what Marcus Peters did this past season to sabotage team spirit.

And Clark definitely likes the NFL way more than he should.

In this ongoing series on the entity Hunt which I am convinced is a critical factor in the interminable and excruciating inexplicable failures of the postseason Kansas City Chiefs, I want to focus on how much the entity NFL also contributes to this wholly execrable state of affairs. And because Clark likes the NFL so much, much because he is such a respected power player in the thing, the incestuous relationship between the two is a factor.

I've written before quite often about this monolith The National Football League. I must say that I really like pro football, and I really like the Kansas City Chiefs' participation in it. In one of these posts I'm thinking I'll elaborate a bit on my own visceral connection to it -- why indeed I spend so much time blogging about it. That's for later.

For now, the NFL.

There are indeed a number of things I legitimately like about the NFL. It is very well organized, and it does a very good job of standardizing the product. There is an appealing consistency that runs through the process and is woven though its history. For instance the 16-game schedule is just about right, and the number of playoff teams and the way the playoffs are arranged is terrific. Lamar Hunt desperately wanted more playoff teams qualifying to have more action and, of course, revenue, but this was one of Lamar's lamest ideas and I hope the current NFL doesn't do it.

The NFL is also well-marketed, simply from an aesthetics perspective. The team names, the colors, the vibrant history, the whole NFL Films thing have all been extraordinary contributions to the game's appeal. I like some of the advances regarding the coordination of the scouting, the combine, and the draft, including making sure a team gets a compensatory pick for lost free agents. And pro football itself is just a really fun game to watch.

But that's it. I'm a fan of the Kansas City Chiefs, and well, Chiefs success has been nonexistent even in times when they've had a pretty damn good team. How often do you see a great postseason Chiefs game from over the past 50 years replayed on the NFL Network? Ha. There are some features showcasing some Chiefs things, every once in a while, like our great linebacker crew of the late 60's or our great defensive backfield of the 80's and early 90's.

The really infuriating thing is the number of times during a Chiefs postseason game you see this: "The Chiefs are the only NFL team in history to ___ [some agonizingly wretched thing]"? How many times do you see this, mostly in the midst of a typically pathetic 4th quarter collapse? Almost all the time. I am sure the Chiefs have some two dozen records for postseason rottenness, seriously.

Here's one of those I simply have to add, just one of those nonplussitudinal things that make this all meaningful. Did you know that this past season the Tennessee Titans had a -22 point differential. Did you catch that?

Minus 22. The Chiefs had a +76 by the way, but yeah, the Chiefs lost their playoff game to a team that was outscored in the regular season by 22 points. I'd venture to say this insane anomaly (ahh, I see, Chiefs again) was pointed out sometime as that game wound down, but think about that -- how many teams with a negative differential even make the playoffs. There may have been a few, but how many have actually won a playoff game? Now yeah, I don't know, and I really don't think I want to know.

Point is, because this kind of thing afflicts the Chiefs incessantly, Hunt is a factor. Indeed, Hunt-plus-the-NFL is an even more liable culprit.

So what is it about the NFL that stinks? Well here's my take. It is my take, which means I know a lot of fans are not on the same page as I am, I understand that. But I do believe beyond my own idiosyncratic recommendations there is some truth to the rank complicity of the thing NFL. This isn't even as much about the NFL but the ways it destroys the Chiefs, and much worse compromises simple human respect and decency.

I will also share that some of these things I've addressed a number of times before, so forgive me for belaboring certain items, but some blogging is certainly about writing and writing until you know what you want to say. I'm always thinking about these things so in a sense, here's the latest Dave take.

Let's do it this way since I've seen others do it. With all due respect to a Roger Goodell who'd say "Okay smart aleck, you try out this job!"

Great. Then yeah...

What I Would Do As Commissioner of the NFL.

- Fire Roger Goodell. Oh, well, if I'm commissioner that's already been done. Thing is, Goodell should've been fired years ago. The Hunt thing involved here is that Clark has made it clear that he is fully on board with Goodell continuing to do things the things he does, things that are clearly detrimental to pro football in this country. The key to this is those are the same exact things that are detrimental to the Kansas City Chiefs.

Without question this is an instance when Clark's loyalty to a proud hard-working individual is a very bad thing.

- End the racialist browbeating. Fomented by the progressively minded media this is the now very common practice of incessantly accusing white people of being inherently guilty of "systemic racism" and urging they be held to account for it. This is racialism, and its very ripe produce is seen in the kneeling, fist-raising, or in-some-way dismissing the national anthem played at NFL games.

Please know I don't really care what the NFL does with the national anthem. The problem comes in a number of distinct areas. One is that the NFL does expect all of its players to take a moment to show respect and stand towards the flag in whatever way the rules state. One of the main reasons it does that is not only to show everyone that the NFL has some demonstrative fondness for the U.S.A. but to respect the fans because they expect it, and really they're the ones paying for it all to happen.

What fans hear NFL players saying to them is this, whether intended or not: "Hey white person you are a racist and you're too dumb to know it so I'm going to do this thing so you can start to listen to me tell you off like this, oh, and thanks for the millions of dollars you give me to say that to you." Sorry, but this is actually in a real sense what those NFL players are telling their fans.

Many fans resent it and you know because they've been leaving the NFL in droves. Who wants to be told that. The ones who stay don't care, agree with them, or simply themselves buy into the propaganda. The players may have a grievance, that's fine, they may make a statement about it, that's fine, they may feel they're being the most righteously principled people about it, that's all very good -- but there is a forum for it.

What do I do as commissioner?

I fully respect their feelings and have a vibrant interaction with as many players as I can about it, especially the ones considered the leaders of this cause. I would then hold a formal conference with those players and listen to them. I would set up an office of racial sensitivity or something similar and promise it would take action on items we can agree upon. If there is already one of these, I would ask what the NFL could do to make it better. I wouldn't announce it or make a big deal about it because I would insist it be about action and not presentation.

Another reason I would handle it that way is because I'd want the chance to go to each and every player who feels strongly about their racialist considerations and plainly ask them, "Would you commit then to stand for the national anthem?" and get an answer from them. If they say "Yes," then we're good. If they say "No," I'd ask them why and see what we can do to make things better. If they are resistant, however, to any reasonable concession or compromise, then I would very nicely and respectfully tell them that they may not play in the NFL then. They are welcome to find employment elsewhere and I would tell them that with a genuine consideration for their welfare. I would address personally each and every player that way.

Sorry, but if the commissioner did this, it is simple:

Problem solved.

What Goodell has done is leave it all to the teams to do what they will with their players. This is a terrible way to approach this. No given team wants to risk losing any of its players as a result of this racialist idiocy when other teams may not follow suit, severely weakening your team on the football field as well as in the public eye. Because of this enabling feature of the commissioner's abject failure in this area, the players have felt they could get away with it all, and it just gets worse.

This of course leads us to the latest major event directly related to the Kansas City Chiefs, and I believe the racialism factor is a critical component of it.

Marcus Peters was traded.

Oh how the Chiefs Kingdom erupted about this. For good reason -- Peters is unquestionably one of the best defensive players in pro football. What is worse is that the Chiefs only got a couple middling draft picks -- and even had to give one up! Please please please. We got totally robbed here people.

Some will say that getting anything for him was good because he was such a bad influence, what with he mercurial outbursts and all of that stuff.

We can work through the good and the bad till we can't breath anymore, just not going to do it now. I will however say this.

The fact that the Kansas City Chiefs are so disrespected by the NFL is a prominent reason we lost Marcus Peters. I will address this more when I write more about competitive duplicity later, but the racialist thing does debilitate the Chiefs in this respect.

With Peters being traded there have been murmurings that it was racially motivated, that Clark didn't like Peters' anthem protests and, well, because those NFL players are so righteous in fighting for the cause then Clark must be a racist. Yes, people have said that -- and I don't even pay much attention to the buzz! Then because of the racialist passions among the most powerful media, the reputation gets spread, and the Chiefs are a racist organization.

Look at this story headline from Arrowhead Pride, really the very best Chiefs website there is. Here's the thing -- why on earth did the site feel the need to put this there? The story itself is really not much of anything, the whole thing merely pointing out that Andy Reid insists Clark had nothing to do with it -- not necessary if there weren't the consideration that he after all did have something to do with it, and even if he did it wouldn't matter unless, of course, there was some squawking about there being some racist element involved.

Whether it is true or not is not even the point (and I don't think anyone with the scantest of brain matter thinks it is true.) The point is this makes it good for the NFL that they now have a reason to enjoy seeing the Chiefs fail -- They don't deserve it because they're racist, or if anything they are now certainly down one of the best D-backs in the league. Again, this fits more with the competitive duplicity aspect regarding the disadvantages small market non-media darling teams must endure, but here the very pronounced racialism crap adds to the factors that unjustly afflict this entity the Kansas City Chiefs.

As commissioner and now prominent member of the power broker class rubbing elbows with much of the politigencia, I may now contribute to sending out this message: Racist discrimination is despicable and if anyone is found to be doing it I wholeheartedly encourage the most proficient prosecution and appropriate penalty. But immediately dispense with the hypnotic embrace of a benighted media-pounded narrative that every white person is guilty of some crime and must be browbeat with some faux-moralistic censure that only serves to enable these wanna-be mandarins' insecurity and distended desire to spout about how virtuous they are. It is sick.

- Reject legal gambling websites clamoring for legitimacy. Another sick item that must go is any possibility that the NFL would even remotely connect in any way with these wretched fantasy football sites -- "Draft Kings" and "Fan Duel" a couple of the most prominent ones. Just being commissioner I can't make them completely against the law, but I would if I could.

So far the NFL has kept its distance from them, but there are rumblings the league may enter into an ugly relationship with them -- you know: "This is the official fantasy football wagering site of the NFL." The sites' overtures are incessantly persistent. Anytime I would be called on to do so, as commissioner I would never cease to remind them what kind of operations they are.

As far as I know, however, the NFL still does nothing to prohibit those sites from using any of the NFL's player names or anything related to the NFL. As commissioner, I would sue to keep any wagering site from doing that, fully protecting the intellectual property of the NFL from being exploited by these rackets.

I would also look into keeping any wagering activity from being used in any way. Of course this would mean Vegas would not be allowed to offer any wagering on any pro football, and the NFL doesn't dare touch Vegas simply because of the massive interest it generates. Yes, it is a truly sad fact that much of the NFL's popularity comes from people who simply want to see if their wager pays off.

The problem all of this presents, of course -- it's been around for years -- is the risk taken when any given sports organization gets in too deep and the play on the field is compromised. How much do we know that happens or doesn't happen? Sure the NFL commissioner wants to reeeally police this, I know, even to an obsessive extent, that's not a bad thing at all -- the stakes for the integrity of the game are on the line.

But if there is even the smallest bit of compromise because of any of the slightest tie to gambling, the teams that the most influential wagerers favor have the advantage. Sure that team could be the Chiefs, but that isn't any better at all. I merely want to Chiefs to win fair-and-square because they've played better football. It just isn't that hard.

- Intercede in the fan-advertising nexus especially with regards to alcohol. Another ugly thing that I would summarily terminate -- any and all relationships with alcohol manufacturers. Yep, I got it, what a dangerous move to take down one of the largest revenue streams. Beer companies.

Here's the thing. People are going to drink alcohol. Okay, so? Why does the NFL have to be a part of endorsing such a destructive thing? Not only do they get truckloads of ad revenue, but they allow certain firms to be "The Official Alcoholic Beverage of the NFL." The NFL has claimed to be socially conscious, what better way to actually show that than to completely end its relationship with the entities responsible for much of the health and social ills we endure?

To those who'd say, "Ahem, it's not the companies that are to blame but the poor behavior of the drinkers," I say that's fine, I understand that, but these companies are still encouraging that behavior with ads shown during NFL games. That ad time is not bought just to provide entertainment. It is obviously intended to convince people to go drink alcohol and they pay millions to make that happen.

The whole "drinking culture" is also extraordinarily repulsive. You can see it in the simple idiotic behavior of many fans, and that is further evidenced in the mostly idiotic things shared in these new kind of sports talk television and radio shows hosted by "the fan." To be honest, I confess in my sports celibacy I've rarely watched them, but what I've seen is abominable -- which is of course one of the reasons I don't watch them. They mostly showcase boorish behavior and the talk features asinine commentary -- all arranged so they can connect with the average fan. This is the average fan? Ugh, this is what the NFL does, appeal to the lowest denominator. Maybe an inconvertible truth, but extraordinarily sad nonetheless.

- Get the officiating on track. Yes, I can't neglect to mention this one yet again. You can call me a conspiracy theorist all you want, I can take it, but I am convinced that the NFL knew the Chiefs were the only team that could actually keep the Patriots from another appearance in the Super Bowl, and really, who do you think they would've wanted in the Super Bowl? The officials' calls in the Titans game were backbreaking, even if just missing the Mariota fumble after Derrick Johnson's sack is the only one we can legitimately call out. That one was still the most critical. That one cost us the game.

Roger Goodell recently said he wants fewer and shorter replay stoppages. The idea of tightening things up is a good one, I'm with him there. But Goodell will never be about the one thing that should happen no matter what.

How about just doing what it takes to get the damn call right?

Goodell's heart may be in the right place, but since I'm now commissioner here's how you do that.

1. Stop intimating (at its best) or flat-out telling the officials (at its worst) to favor certain teams. Sorry but the Scorecasting evidence proves that the officials whether unwittingly (at best) or deliberately (at worst) make calls that favor certain teams. The Chiefs evidences are also proof that they do this. It wasn't only the Mariota non-fumble but there was the Hill non-TD-catch from the Dolphins game, and I mention it because in this post about half-way in I describe in detail this phenomena, related directly to the behavior of officials in a given game.

For those who like a little less of a conspiracy-minded take, here're several significant practical changes to clean up the officiating.

2. Expand the eligible plays to everything. Yes I understand this is challenging, but please. If a defender blatantly commits a pass interference call it should be reviewed. I do know this is really getting into the realm of interpretation by somebody, and the officials do the best they can. I do believe most times they get it right, and if it is close or questionable then I agree it should be left alone. Fine. Receiver and defender jostle a bit before the ball arrives, fine. Even with regards to the Chiefs I'm fine with calls that are borderline -- let them go, it was close enough. (Yes, those kinds of calls most times go against the Chiefs, but those aren't the ones that really kill us.)

There are several obvious one that must be called out. What is the way to do that? How about we do this next thing...

3. Have two officials in a booth with television monitors in front of them and give them initial call privileges. Now you have two sets of eyes looking at the same play. If either one sees something amiss they can blow their "whistle," simply alerting the on-field referee to stop play in order to, yeah, ahem, JUST GET THE PLAY CORRECT.

This will also allow the on-field officials to breathe easy that they don't have to wonder "Hmm did I get that call right" after working as best as they can to get it right and then going crazy wondering if they should blow the whistle and stop the offense from rushing to the line to keep a review from happening -- a really stupid part of all this that must change also.

If the two booth officials agree that there's been some poor call or discrepancy with a call then the referee's job is easy. If it is really close or controversial and they disagree, however, then the on-field referee makes the call and we're all good.

It also makes it easier in the sense that when both booth officials agree then it must be a pretty obvious call to get right. This also means, honestly, the initial booth call should not happen too often. In a sense this is the thing that will indeed result in fewer and shorter review stoppages.

Hunt clearly has control of ball, even when it touches the ground
it is still firmly in his grasp, but then after turning and lying on his back
he slightly bobbles it - apparently making it incomplete
4. Return to common sense rules. The NFL has done some really ding-dong things with rules, and there are a number of them. Two in particular I want to call out.

First, the catch rule. Everyone is up in arms about this one, and rightly so. While some more high-profile rulings against obvious catches got people's ire, the Chiefs have also been victims, this year most notably when Kareem Hunt was not allowed the TD catch (shown in the photograph) because of what the officials surmised about that ridiculous rule. (The non-catch ended up not hurting the Chiefs in this late-season game against the Chargers.)

So what catch rule should be adopted? Why is this so difficult? Catch: grab ball, a full second of possession, a football move like two steps. The end. Who cares how much the ground bats it about after there is a real-live catch made. The Dallas Cowboys receiver Butch Johnson did less with his iconic TD catch in Super Bowl XII.

Right after Johnson makes the catch he stretches his body
into the end zone, then immediately drops the ball.
Still a touchdown!
Incidentally, while I didn't watch any of the Super Bowl this year, I did see a highlight of the last touchdown the Eagles scored, one in which the receiver caught the ball, held it, and made some deliberate football move -- the whole package, what could be wrong with that? When he entered the end zone and slammed the ball into the turf, it shifted about in his hands. Sure enough, everyone's wondering if the obvious catch would actually hold up in the official's sometimes demented mind -- I mean we've seen it so often. Referee Gene Steratore actually grew a pair and after a video review wisely ruled it a completed catch and touchdown. Smart man.

It just isn't that hard, folks.

The second ding-dong rule of note is the 33-yard extra point kick. I know some will say this is a minor thing, but it really isn't, and it doesn't even have to do with the fact that it makes the point-after-touchdown harder. It actually doesn't, at least not by much. The point is it was a rule put in place simply because Roger Goodell-types wanted to spice up the game.

Please. This isn't American Idol.

The 33-yard PAT rule is also not good because it removes the possibility of faking a kick in order to try for two. Sure a team may try the fake for two from the 15, but still, you get my point.

One more rule change as I think about it, one that showed up in a fine Jon Bois piece about kickoffs. I'd consider adopting the "4th-and-15" rule for kickoffs. Kickoffs have been messed with in order to reduce the number of injuries that happen on them, which is a very good thing. But they're still there, they still result in too many injuries when a player runs it out, and the way it is touchbacks happen most times anyway.

The "4th-and-15" procedure is when the "kicking team's" offense simply takes the field with the ball at the 35 yard-line and it is as if it were 4th down and 15 yards to go. If they want to punt -- this serves as the kickoff -- they may, and will most likely do so. But if they want to do an "on-sides kick" -- which itself lays out conditions that are likely to result in more injuries -- then they can just run a play. If they get the 15 yards or more for the 1st down, they have the ball right there. What if they score a touchdown on the play? That's fine too! But if they fail to get the first down, the opposing team gets the ball there with a very short field.

I'd talk with smart people who have pro football's best interests in mind -- I do understand there are some liabilities with the 4th-and-15 kickoff. Still as commissioner I'd very much consider good rule changes like this one, and reject the very bad ones like that longer PAT kick.

- Reduce injuries. Sorry, but there are things the NFL can do to limit the number of injuries there are, especially concussions. As commissioner I would promptly implement a number of policies and introduce a number of safety features that would definitely be instrumental in keeping players' health intact for the duration of their lives yet still keep the game vibrant and exciting.

Straight away this is something that has, yes, also debilitated the Chiefs playoff chances far too often. In Indianapolis on that fateful January day in 2014 the Chiefs sideline was like a military infirmary. Most recently in the Tennessee game the momentum shifted the most when that Titans defender unnecessarily slammed into Travis Kelce's head giving him a concussion and taking him out of the game.

You know, I've seen the NFL Films highlight reel of the Chiefs' Super Bowl IV win a number of times, and the last time I watched it I noticed something in it I remember always seeing but never really considered. There was Otis Taylor getting off the turf very woozily, then having smelling salts shoved in his face. Now I don't know if that incident was before or after his iconic sideline catch and touchdown run -- it is interesting because his touchdown, as much as it was the game-clincher, occurred in the 3rd quarter. Yeah, huh, neither team scored points in the 4th quarter of that game.

Someday I'll watch the whole game -- it's on Youtube and I've seen parts of it, but it's there and you may watch the whole thing. Did Otis suffer a concussion before his big play? Would he have been out of the game because of the concussion protocol? I'm not saying anything about what would've been one way or another -- I am wholly in favor of an even more strict concussion protocol if you want to know.

What we do know is that there were 281 reported concussions in the NFL over the course of the 2017 season, and that is just the reported ones. We do know that players have suffered terribly from CTE, yet they're making progress in diagnosing it early. How about we do reasonable things to keep from having to make excuses for retired players' lives and livelihood being cut short, just shrugging by saying "they signed up for this gig didn't they?" Sorry but that attitude is reprehensible.

Here's what I'd do as commissioner. I'd eliminate all helmet-to-helmet hits -- yes, exactly like the one that injured Travis Kelce. I understand that helmets will still clang against helmets, I got that. But the hit against Kelce is one I'd outlaw because that specific one was completely unnecessary, but excused because "Kelce was a runner" and all that crap. We can take some time and identify the hits that could easily be avoided and still allow for authentic tackling -- much of which the players already know about.

How about redesigning the helmet? With the technology we have available and the medical advances we've made I can't understand how we can't make a helmet that does a much better job of absorbing much more of the impact of hits.

I'd also outlaw the kinds of plays that injured Odell Beckham Jr. This year he was injured for the season in a gruesome take down -- literally -- when a Chargers defender grabbed him as he went up high for a pass and yanked him down on his ankles. Another was when Aaron Rodgers injured his shoulder when after sacking him the lineman pretty much just dropped his body on top of him -- completely unnecessary. I agree injuries occur when players run over other players just doing their jobs, but the kinds of injuries that happened to Beckham and Rodgers are simply particular ones that can be expressly prohibited.

I know the NFL does things to monitor this and if an illegal hit is determined to have taken place after the game is over and all is said and done, then legitimate action can be taken against the offender. I'd just like to step up that enforcement, work on some things to function as more of a deterrence, again strictly in the interest of keeping the players healthy. My goodness when your best players are on crutches on the sideline all the time, it does impact the bottom line! I'm just as interested in them as human beings who should be afforded a future without any kind of mental impairment because of their participation in the game.

- Call out the duplicity for what it is and restore true competitive integrity. Who does the NFL really want to see in the playoffs? Really, answer that question for me honestly. Let's put it this way, do you think that powerful people in the ivory towers of pro football, not just in the executive offices but among the media, the commercial interests, and any other power broker who benefits financially from whatever it is that happens that is this thing NFL -- Do you think those people ever think to themselves or hope for or even let out that they'd like a larger market media darling team to win at a given time?

Is there even a single advertiser who brazenly expresses a genuine desire to see -- and pay more for -- a New York-Los Angeles championship matchup as opposed to a, say, Kansas City-New Orleans one? I believe the advertising rates are already set, but please. Is it possible any of them gleefully recognize the far larger audience of the former and simply wouldn't mind that much if even a few things were tweaked to try to make it that way?

Seriously, do any one of the major influencers of NFL things ever feel these things in any way to any degree?

If you say "No" you are either delusional or copping out on addressing this issue. If you say "Yes" and it is indeed true that should any of these people do that, however few it may be, then

Competitive duplicity does indeed truthfully exist.

And yes, it is a slap in the face of the Chiefs Kingdom.

Let's just cut to the chase: The NFL loathe having the Chiefs successful in the postseason. Look at it this way. What do you think these power brokers the world 'round thought about this slate of teams among those participating in the NFL playoffs this year? They were:

Atlanta. Buffalo. Carolina. Jacksonville. Kansas City. Minnesota. New Orleans. Tennessee. 

Yeah. Ee-yhee.

Fortunately for them (or in some instances I think more purposefully) when it was all done they got the New England-Philadephia Super Bowl matchup they coveted -- ::whew:: Sure most of the country (they were actually polled on this) desperately wanted the Patriots to lose for once, but that's just part of the appeal -- more people will watch just so they have a real shot at reveling in a Patriots loss on the biggest stage of sports entertainment.

The ratings for all the games involving the aforementioned teams were abysmal. Certainly the racialist stuff was a factor in pushing fans away, yes. The Kansas City-Tennessee playoff game was the least watched playoff game in five years. Two podunk Midwest teams playing at a time when people could be out and about on a fun Saturday afternoon picnicking and hiking, west coast -- Saturday early evening preparing for a nice night on the town, east coast.

Here's the slate the ivory tower dwellers salivate over (be honest -- you know it is true):

AFC: Cleveland, Los Angeles, New England, New York, Oakland/Las Vegas, Pittsburgh

NFC: Chicago, Dallas, Green Bay, Los Angeles, New York, San Francisco

Wah-oww! That would just be the greatest because the entire NFL would get gazillions. (Yeah, I know: this slate isn't possible because there are no representative AFC South and NFC South teams, but the powers-that-be really cringe if any of those teams are successful.) I am convinced the NFL and whoever has the capacity to do so in whatever way that is do engage in competitive duplicity to make these teams much more likely to enter the playoffs. 

Look at the possible matchups! Cleveland-Pittsburgh. Dallas-San Francisco. Green Bay-Chicago. New York-New England. Pittsburgh-Oakland. Los Angeles-Dallas. Any combination works in some delightful (and profitable) way!

Furthermore to what degree does Clark hope for these eventualities, merely for the reason that when the NFL does well, the Chiefs do well even if the Chiefs themselves are not in the playoffs? The Giants or Jets or Cowboys or Patriots in, good for them and the NFL. The Chiefs in? Only good for the Chiefs. If he does so in even the smallest way, then Clark is part of the problem.

And this thing "Hunt" splays a bit more of its brutality over the Chiefs Kingdom.

This even relates to the Marcus Peters situation. Let me ask you this question. Was it easier for Marcus Peters to act like a total aye-hole because he knew it might eventuate in his dismissal from a team that is not one of the favored teams? In fact when this deal came around last week I came across a remark by Ian Rapaport, a top NFL beatwriter, who said something about "leveraging a small market."

What does that mean, "leveraging a small market"? I'm not sure, but I think it means the Chiefs could've enjoyed seeing another team or other teams involved who had no real interest in Peters but who'd bid in order to raise the price. Because only one team expressed interest in Peters it was much more likely the Chiefs would get diddly for him -- and they did. They should've gotten at least a No. 1 pick, but the price was artificially low because only one team was interested. My gut tells me this was not because no one else wanted him but because they didn't want to make the Chiefs any better, and the NFL just looked the other way.

Look at where Peters ended up -- in large market media darling Los Angeles, perfect for him, but terrible for the Chiefs. Who's wagging the dog here?

I really wonder about this: Do any Chiefs players chafe at the Chiefs being treated as poorly as they are in this environment, and do they have an unspoken desire to leave? Are they tired of seeing Hunt show up in every stinkin' playoff game they play? Do they even care as long as they get a nice paycheck? Or to their endearing credit do most genuinely appreciate the very good things about this thing Kansas City Chiefs?

Do they have some measure of appreciation for Clark Hunt?

I do wonder. Not saying they don't! I actually do wonder because I don't really know.

As commissioner then I'm going to ensure that each team is treated fairly and above board. Sure the NFL says it does that. Don't think the NFL is factually duplicitous now with regards to the Chiefs? How about this item, a definitive way the NFL specifically targeted the Chiefs and actually put a real hurt on their ability to improve their team.

A few years ago the Chiefs sought soon-to-be free agent Jeremy Maclin and did things in their interactions with him that were considered tampering. As a penalty the Chiefs lost a couple of draft picks. The problem is that teams do what the Chiefs did all the time. When they've done it the NFL looks the other way. Sure they should change the rules to be -- yes -- fair and above board with every team. Instead the NFL went after the Chiefs. This article explains it all. Its title is about how Clark and Andy should be furious with the NFL. Please, every single fan and member of the Chiefs Kingdom is already furious about it.

There may be other things the NFL could do to be better which I haven't covered here, I'm sure I'd think of other things and new things will arise. Ultimately in whatever I would do as commissioner I would give the highest and greatest respect to what it is that is right and true and just, even as it relates to love and mercy and grace. The current commissioner is really just sold out to the ideas he thinks will make him look good through whatever the NFL and its power brokers tell him. Regarding the Chiefs, I just want what is just and fair in the NFL front office to translate to the playing field, and it just hasn't happened. Kinda funny that I want justice -- that's all, just an honest evaluation of what's going on -- ironically much like those anthem protesters, interesting isn't it.

I don't ask for any special advantages at all, of course -- but I also don't want the things listed above to destroy the chances for my team to win football games, or even more, for the Chiefs Kingdom to thrive. Things will get better, however, only if people honestly confront those things and want the same just and righteous things.

More on all this next time, and yes, there will be more positives! They're there! We'll get to them!
___

(Episode V)
___

Thursday, February 22, 2018

The Devastating Hunt, Episode III

Clark Hunt likes Andy Reid.

One of the truly endearing things about Clark is his loyalty to those given the task of nurturing the Chiefs Kingdom. It is a hallmark of the Hunt legacy. Yes this entire blog series is about examining this thing Hunt that somehow afflicts Chiefs success through the eons, and indeed when a power broker within the organization stays with an ineffectual operative for far too long, it is painfully detrimental.

On the other hand, Clark's loyalty can be a good thing. It means leadership has faith, patience, and confidence in you to get the job done. At times Hunt has done that well, at other times, not so well. Clark himself has always wrestled with when to move and when not to, and to his great credit he is always deeply contemplatively considering everything, the Chiefs and the individual, whenever he must make a difficult personnel decision.

Right now the braintrust is Clark-Brett-Andy. We'll talk much more about Brett in later posts, but for right now...

What about Andy?

Let's face it, Chiefs fans do consider themselves fortunate to have Andy Reid as head coach. He has led the Chiefs to winning regular season records for all five of his years with us. He does that with the quite accomplished qualities that enthusiastically encourage Clark to keep him signed and sealed for as long as he wants, really. Reid is genuinely terrific at managing the team, keeping all the pieces working as they should. The troops practice and play with purpose and they have a robust respect for the man -- a lot of that is because Reid demonstrates a vibrant appreciation for the contributions of each of his players. He is also a tremendously skilled play designer and game-plan arranger.

And from what I hear he's a genius working with quarterbacks. Chiefs fans are slavering to taste the fruits of Pat Mahomes' progress -- this is a veraciously exciting benefit of Clark's intensely deliberative style: Mahomes can be confident the Chiefs will stand by him. A work colleague mentioned that he'd recently seen on television ESPN guys analyzing the optimum quarterback-coach situations for next season, and they felt the Chiefs had the best one. Very very very cool -- who can't wait for next season to start?!

These are the areas in which Reid deftly excels.

But then there is the very bad Andy Reid. In three key areas Reid sticks out like a sore buttock. You know what they are.

First, he simply cannot be organic -- this is one of the critical factors to our continued playoff failures. Often in the heat of a postseason battle you must rely on your intuition and do things that might deviate a bit from the original plan, simply because you just know this player or that player can do something for you that you really need to win that game. This feature of good postseason coaching has been woefully absent in all four of our playoff losses in those five years, three of which were lost by a total of four points. For cryin' out loud Andy get your face out of that play-sheet once in a while!

Second, he simply does not make the right adjustments. Sure enough, before that playoff loss to Tennessee I predicted that to win, even against a much weaker team, Reid simply must make adjustments to counter their adjustments, even make further adjustments to adjust for their added adjustments. He didn't. He flat-out didn't like he didn't in those other playoff losses, and it relates to the failure to be organic because he stubbornly refuses to go in a direction that is not The Game Plan. This just kills us.

For a bit of the ugliness of that Tennessee game, you know we scored zero points in the second half. I went ahead and looked, checked to see if we'd ever done that in the regular season. Sure enough, we scored points in every second half of the regular season, quite a few even, averaging 13.4 second-half points over the 16 games. Yeah, go ahead: ::whimper:: The fewest second-half points we scored was in the Giants game, when we had 6. Horrible -- but at least we had 6! The most? That first splendid win against New England, we scored 28 second-half points. I hear more whimpering -- that's okay, I got ya.

Really, that Tennessee game was the most horrific evidence that Andy Reid just won't be organic or adjust as he should. Now maybe he can learn, maybe as he comes into his own as a veteran, seasoned, lion-of-the-NFL-coaching-fraternity with something left in the tank -- maybe he'll humbly dedicate himself enough to work at getting that going.

Third -- and you'll see this ties in with other two as well -- he won't admit when he's messed up. I did not watch it because it was too agonizing, but I'd heard about it and I'd seen a very brief clip of it, and it was painful -- in his post-game press conference he actually had the temerity to deflect responsibility away from himself and blame everyone else for not doing what they were supposed to do.

Excuse me, but this just destroys all that great leadership stuff you'd already engendered among the Chiefs Kingdom. Even if this guy or that guy didn't come through on the field, as a strong leader you take the hit.

I can't help but think of something notable in a Joe Montana biography I'm reading right now. In every instance he possibly could Montana would always give his players the benefit of the doubt and assume the responsibility for anything that went wrong. Sure he'd urge his players to do this thing or that thing, but whenever he did he gave them an enormous amount of confidence that he'd come through for them.

See, Joe Montana had that thing I've mentioned frequently before in this blog.

He had "got-it." It is what separates the winners from the also-rans, and I'm sorry, but there is a Chiefs arrowhead right next to the word also-ran in the dictionary.

I think back to the Alabama-Georgia NCAA football championship game this year played the Monday night after the Chiefs-Titans debacle. There you watched tons of got-it coach Nick Saban pulling his regular quarterback for a freshman who hadn't played a snap all year, a player who eventually led Alabama to the win for the title.

Huh, Andy Reid, really, shouldn't you have been truly organic in our game and put in Pat Mahomes when Alex Smith was simply not getting it done in the second half of that game? Showed the Titans a totally different look like Saban did to the very good Georgia defense? After all, we all saw what Mahomes did just the week before in mile-high conditions against one of the best defenses in the league. Did you miss that? For more on this, I had a special post in middle of the regular season related to our exasperation with Reid not going with Mahomes during the regular season when Smith was playing horribly.

Now maybe sticking with Smith was the right call then, I understand. Smith did finish the regular season well for us, that's fine.

But then I also think this. Here's the wrap-up to all of this.

How much of Reid's failures and the contemptible lack of got-it is because of Hunt?

Not Clark, just Hunt.

Stram was great -- there was still Hunt. Levy was a godsend -- we all know what Lamar did with that. Schottenheimer was amazing -- ahh, Hunt. Vermeil was incredible -- but, well, Hunt. Reid is a phenomenal coach -- Hunnnt. 

Just a reminder, when Reid coached the Eagles from 1999 to 2012, the Eagles made the playoffs nine times and won at least one playoff game in the first seven of those times. His team won ten playoff games over that span, going to the Super Bowl in the 2004 season. For the Chiefs he's 1-4, already suffering three one-and-outs. Hunt?

Here's something I think about, another historical note that to me adds to the whole protracted intergenerational thing. To me it does, even though there is so much more, and so much I don't know or understand. But I'm sharing this particular item here anyway.

Go back to 1960, when Chiefs Kingdom started. Here's Lamar, a man who was nicknamed "Games" because of his passion for playing games and enjoying sports and desperately wanting to win -- here he is starting his own pro football team he certainly wanted to win all the time. But to make that meaningful he had to get a whole bunch of teams to win against, so of course he starts the AFL. If you were Lamar, what precisely would you want to have happen here?

Naturally you want your team to win most games by scores of 21-20 and be champions at least almost every year. Indeed Lamar probably had an edge because the AFL was his league created so the Texans-later-Chiefs would be successful. The franchise did have three titles in the ten years of the AFL's existence.

Here's the thing -- Lamar was sensitive to that conception. He wanted his darling team to win but he couldn't look at all like the whole thing was stilted in his favor.

Sure enough, in the very first game the Texans ever played in the entirety of the AFL -- Saturday September 10 1960 there in the Los Angeles Coliseum against the Chargers -- Lamar's team jumps out to a 20-7 halftime lead. He very openly declares at the time that maybe the Texans shouldn't be so dominant. Well guess what happened. Los Angeles came back and won 21-20. Lamar vows never to take anything for granted again.

There is just something about the psychic in that whole thing which to me has affected the Chiefs throughout their history.

I've been thinking about a couple more things I'd thought about a bit more from my last post that I feel are connected to this.

That the Chiefs have lost a playoff game to every AFL team except the Bengals (whom they've never played) at least once. Sorry, but that is just weird. Look, here's the record! -- the Chiefs postseason record by AFL team:

Boston (New England) 0-1
Buffalo 1-2
Cincinnati 0-0
Denver 0-1
Houston (Tennessee) 2-1
Los Angeles (San Diego) 0-1
Miami 0-3
New York 1-1
Oakland 2-1

Other teams (whom they've played):
Baltimore 0-1
Green Bay 0-1
Houston Texans 1-0
Indianapolis 0-4
Minnesota 1-0
Pittsburgh 1-1

Among all teams the only ones the Chiefs have played and not lost to are the Texans and Vikings. Meanwhile the Patriots Broncos Chargers Dolphins Ravens Packers and Colts have never lost to the Chiefs.

Then there is this one. There're those eleven seasons when the Chiefs have had a winning record but not made the playoffs. I thought about that too and thought, huh, really, is that a lot? Are there other teams with as many? I did then peek at just a few teams and found none that had as many as the Chiefs had. Now I didn't look at a Bears or a Cardinals, teams that've been around for almost 100 years, they've got to have quite a few. Maybe sometime when I need some distraction time I'll look at more teams, just to see.

But eleven winning seasons with no playoff appearance in 58 years of existence -- most of those seasons featuring ten teams entering the postseason -- that has to be a lot. What this means is the Chiefs have had a lot of 9-7 type seasons where one more win for a 10-6 mark would've gotten them in the playoffs. Which means that, likely --

Eleven times the Chiefs have had even more single heartbreak games late in a season that kept them from a shot at glory.

I can think of a few right off the top of my head.

There was 1996. We were at 9-4 after a convincing Thanksgiving day win over the Lions, then couldn't win another game. The last game of the season was in Buffalo and certainly within reach, but we couldn't get it done. We could've backed in with a 9-7 record, but the Falcons' Morten Andersen (a Hall-of-Famer who later even played for the Chiefs) missed a 30-yard field goal to let the Jaguars off the hook for that playoff spot instead.

How about 1999? We're at 9-6 and a win over the Raiders at home and we're in. We leap out to a 17-0 lead, then it gets tight for the rest of the game until their kicker ties it with under a minute left, then wins it in overtime.

Or even recently, 2014? In a game against Arizona with Kansas City ahead and in control late, Travis Kelce caught a pass deep in Cardinals territory that really would've iced the game. We win that game and we're 10-6, a record that would've qualified us for the playoffs. Instead after Kelce was lying flat on his back in firm possession of the ball, a Cardinals defender batted the ball out of his hands and the officials ruled it a fumble. Turnover, ball to Arizona, they march down, score, and eventually win.

Now I KNOW there are dozens of other instances when these kinds of things happen to other teams, I got that, I'm with you -- come on Dave what's the point...

The point is undeniably that this stuff afflicts the Chiefs far more than other teams.

And I KNOW there are a hundred other factors that afflict the Chiefs in these regards, many of them questionable things related to Hunt, several of which we can see and know about.

Some of those other things are related to the present NFL itself, and that will be the subject of my next post. Enough writing for now! Whew.

Until then...
___

As I put this blog post together, major stuff has been going down with our team. I couldn't help but notice that the Chiefs are trading Marcus Peters, and have been working on this deal for some time. Major ramifications emerge from that, with some critical facets having to do with the way the NFL treats the Chiefs. It's all breaking right now, so we'll have some time to digest and then address more fully in next week's edition of "The Devastating Hunt..."
___

(Episode IV)
___

Thursday, February 15, 2018

The Devastating Hunt, Episode II

There is hope. There is. I'll get to that, a lot. Sometime, very soon, I will.

It is just there has been that despair. Too much of it. That's what this series is all about.

Some may reasonably say move on, forget about it, today's a new day. Yeah, I understand the sentiment, I do. And I will always be optimistic about the Chiefs, even through the worst. But some add okay then what's the point of all this going over the past. It is simple, this blog series is about saying there is something somewhere somehow that impacts the Kansas City Chiefs in a wholly detrimental way, and I'm just trying to look at it, for the exclusive purpose of seeing good Chiefs things from it, that's the point. As I shared in the previous post, I confess there's a lot I don't know and there're a lot of people I have nothing against.

For instance Clark.

Here's a very hopeful thing -- an update of sorts. As any Chiefs fan knows Alex Smith was traded to the Redskins for a third round pick and a fine D-back. Now I'd be happy if we got a box of Fig Newtons for him -- nothing against Smith, really, but he was incapable of getting us to the promised land, for a lot of reasons. That's been hashed to death, not going to get into it. Pat Mahomes is good to go out there, let's get that happening already.

I will say, however, that I'm thrilled we got that pick and a terrific coverage guy on defense -- apparently I'd heard Redskins fans were furious they gave him up. Cool, we got him now.

Thing is, I'd heard later that Clark vetoed any trade that would've sent Smith to a divisional foe -- read that: Broncos. This is a terrific move. It means Clark is being a leader, making the right call here, and I believe it is.

Unless... Did Clark actually contact the Broncos? Really? Could he have said, "Look, Alex Smith is a phenomenal talent with at least a couple years left. What can you offer?" If they asked, "What do you want?" could we have just said, "We'll take the next two No. 1's, Demaryius Thomas, and Chris Harris"? See, could they have said that? Unlikely, but did we try? Did we ask for that and see what happens? Would half that deal be better than what we got from Washington?

Now maybe they did do that, maybe the Washington deal was the best we could get -- and I believe that deal was pretty good to be honest.

And I'd like to think Clark is blowing out the "Hunt" thing, the fruits of which will reveal itself in all its glory in next year's divisional playoff game at Arrowhead -- and beyond.

For you see, there is still Hunt.

There it is. Look. You cannot deny looking at it. Go ahead, try. Try to avert your eyes, you can't. But that's okay because again, the only reason to view the ugliness is so maybe we can identify what is going on that is making it happen. I have some ideas, some legitimate ones, ones I've shared a number of times here, and we'll get to some of them. For now, some more history. I want to do this just to show you, would you indulge me? It is also good for the therapy, thanks for joining me.

I had a hypothesis, and I went about testing it. It is as follows.

The Chiefs have the worst playoff record of any team, particularly in relation to its regular season record.

I went about compiling all the NFL teams franchise regular season win-loss percentages and their playoff win-loss percentages and compared them all. Would the Chiefs be the worst? Let's test it. Here's what I discovered.

First of all, some teams have hundreds and hundreds of games played in their long histories -- the most are by teams like the Bears, Packers, Lions, and believe it or not, the Cardinals which have all been around since the early 1920's. Comparatively other teams like the Ravens or Texans have not played many games at all.

The best overall regular season records are as follows, along with their winning percentages:

1. Dallas .573
2. Green Bay .567
3. Chicago .564
4. Miami .559
5. New England .559
6. Minnesota .547
7. San Francisco .544
8. Baltimore .541
9. New York Giants .540
10. Denver .538
11. Oakland .529
12. Pittsburgh .529
13. Indianapolis .528
14. Kansas City .524
15. Cleveland .511
16. Seattle .507
17. Washington .504

These are all the teams with winning records. Note the first part of my hypothesis is proven:

The Chiefs have actually been, overall, a pretty decent team during the regular season.

What is striking is that even though they rank 14th, they have been that good. They have a winning percentage pretty comparable to Pittsburgh's and Oakland's, even though those two teams have a much greater reputation for football success. One reason for Pittsburgh's lower-than-expected number is it was absolutely atrocious for years upon years before it began its run in the early 70's. Even so that run has netted them 36 postseason wins including six Super Bowl titles. Oakland's is a bit depressed because they were very bad when the AFL started and have been pretty bad over the past several years. Even so the Raiders have 25 postseason wins and three Super Bowl titles.

The Chiefs? They have nine. Nine postseason wins total total total.

Just before I did this data compilation, I started thinking, huh, you know, the Chiefs have had quite a number of winning seasons! My brain did a little mental inventory of their regular season history, and voila! There it was.

The '60's. During the 60's they dominated the AFL, and they were still really pretty good in the early 70's. Did you know they had winning records from 1970 to 1973 but only made the playoffs once in that time?

The '70's and '80's. They stank in the late 70's, but had that splendid year in 1981, then again in 1986, and in and around all that they were mediocre, sporting 8-8 marks in 1980 and 1984 and an 8-7-1 mark in 1989 -- not horrible by any means. In fact I'd always remembered that in that 1984 season four of the Chiefs losses were by a total of five points. Neat.

The '90's. We all know how dominant they were in the 90's, winning more regular season games than any team but the Bills. Yep, for review, the Chiefs were better regular season-wise in that decade than the Cowboys (three Super Bowl titles), the Broncos (two), the 49ers, Packers, Giants, and Redskins (one each). The Chiefs won a whopping three playoff games total over the course of that decade.

The '00's and beyond. We had an 8-8 season in 2002, but then exploded to 13-3 in '03, adding more winning seasons in '05 and '06. We thoroughly sucked from '07 to '09 and again in the very notorious 2012, but had a fine season in 2010. And of course we've had a winning season every year since 2013 -- five straight years.

To boot, we have a winning record against every other team in the AFC West. We've also had eleven seasons of winning records when we did not make the playoffs. That seems like a lot, but I simply haven't looked at the other teams in this area to see if it is or not. I'm sure there are a quite a few times 9-7 teams have not made the playoffs, I got that, but eleven times for a single team in their history? I'd have to think that ranks pretty high to be honest with you.

Every once in a while I hear an announcer, mostly during a television broadcast, speak about THE STORIED HISTORY OF THE KANSAS CITY CHIEFS. You know what I feel about every time I hear that? I chafe. It is uncomfortable. I think, "Uggh, he's just saying that. I know our history is actually really crappy to be honest with you. I know our history of postseason chokes is legendary -- how could he say such a thing?"

But you know, our regular season history is actually pretty stellar! It's just I viscerally feel that it doesn't quite justify the ingratiating remarks made by announcers...

And it doesn't change what's happened to this team in the postseason.

That leads to the second part of the hypothesis. How does this regular season success compare to our postseason failures, and I'm venturing to say it is the worst, by far, and any other team. The yawning chasm between our regular season success and our postseason failures is the largest, that's what I say. Let's see...

Here are the rankings for postseason winning percentage, from worst on down. I'm not going very far because the Chiefs appear so soon, of course.

1. Cincinnati .263 (What? A team worse than the Chiefs?! We'll get to that, stay tuned...)
2. Kansas City .333
3. Detroit .350
4. Los Angeles Chargers .393
5. Tampa Bay .400

The numerical difference percentage-wise from regular to postseason for the Chiefs is an earth-shattering .191. That's pretty major. Here are the rankings in size of differences:

1. Cincinnati .194
2. Kansas City .191
3. Minnesota .139
4. Detroit .110
5. Los Angeles Chargers .105

Again these are measured drops from how they did in the regular season to how they did in the postseason. Interesting that Minnesota comes in after the Chiefs on the good regular season-bad postseason flunky list, but the difference is that Minnesota has still won 20 playoff games in its history (to 29 losses). Yes the Vikings have had crushing playoff (and Super Bowl!) losses, but their regular season record is so good (6th in NFL history!) that this make sense. I also can't help but think about how Minnesota was most notorious for so disrespectfully shafting Lamar Hunt when the AFL started -- I just wonder if there is something about that in the mix.

Let's talk about the other sore festering thumb that's shoved into all of this: Cincinnati.

The Bengals right now are riding a seven-game losing streak in the playoffs. Their latest loss, a Wild Card Game for the 2015 season, was a disaster -- they were comfortably leading Pittsburgh late when Vontaze Burfict and Adam "Pacman" Jones committed the most egregious personal foul penalties that essentially cost them the game. Ironically this game was the one played on the same day right after the Chiefs won their only postseason game in 25 years. Huh, an odd connection between the most brutal playoff teams ever.

But look at this team, the Cincinnati Bengals. What is their history like? I don't know 98% of it, but I do know some. And I surely can't say one thing or another about certain things, but I can write about my thoughts anyway.

The Bengals originated in 1966 by Paul Brown, who'd wanted to have his own franchise after he did amazingly innovative things for the NFL with the Cleveland Browns (not named after him). With his coaching skill Brown led the team to several pro football championships in the 1940's and 1950's. With a different coach the Brown-built Browns team even won the NFL title in 1964.

But that was the end for the Browns. They have never been to a Super Bowl and this past season they finished 0-16, one of the few teams ever to go completely winless in a season.

The very interesting thing is in 1995 owner Art Modell considered the Browns were going nowhere in Cleveland, and he moved the team to Baltimore completely reinventing the team as the Ravens. (A newer Browns version was created in 1999 and that is the one in the league right now.) Here's the interesting part.

The Ravens have been phenomenally successful in the postseason.

In fact virtually right outta the gate in 2000, the spankin' new Baltimore Ravens won the Super Bowl. They did it again in 2012, and each time they had to win four postseason games, entering as a Wild Card team and running the table. The Ravens actually have the very best postseason winning percentage of any team in NFL history, a .652 clip. To amplify this I looked at the records of these teams in first game playoff games, whether Wild Card or Divisional.

The Bengals are 3-11 in first playoff games in their history. Yes, they've only had three years of their history when they've even won a playoff game at all. They did go to the Super Bowl in two of those years, losing to the 49ers both times, which represents another intriguing twist to all of this which I'll get to in a minute.

Meanwhile the Ravens are 8-2 in first playoff games. 8-2! Oh the envy of Chiefs fans the world-round. Thing is, I then thought, huh, I wonder what the Ravens regular season record was for each of those eight wins... I should compare it to the Chiefs regular season record for each of their 14 first game losses.

Yes, you read that right. The Chiefs have 14 first game losses in their postseason history (make sure you vomit with the window open please). The Chiefs have a 6-14 record in first postseason games. Yet another stomach-churning truth -- they've only enjoyed a pathetically scant six years (of 58 years in existence) when they've won at least a single playoff game, and one of those was that 1962 AFL Championship when they were the Texans. Otherwise, yep, there it is, '66, '69, '91, '93, and '15, tha's it. Ughck.

So, what is the Chiefs regular season record in those 14 years? Average: 10.9-4.7. Pretty close to an 11-5 record each of the 14 times they went into the playoffs and lost straight away. The Ravens? Regular season record for each of their 8 wins? 10.8-5.2.

Yeah.

Uggggck.

It is pretty close, but still.

The Chiefs have been better. The Chiefs went into the playoffs 14 times (of 20 all together) with a better record on average than the Ravens and lost each time. The Ravens on the other hand went into the playoffs 8 times (of 10 all together) with a worse record on average than the Chiefs and won each time.

Now yes I did kind of cherry-pick these two teams to compare, but hey, I do need rich meaningful Chiefs commiseration, that's the whole point of this. And I do believe much of this is something I've shared a number of times before, and that is for most of the Ravens success they've had Joe Flacco, a very fine drafted and developed quarterback. (Just point-of-fact, in six first-playoff-games Flacco is 6-0 -- he has never lost a first-playoff-game.) The Chiefs on the other hand have had throw-in QB's (as fine as some have been!) and none have ever been able to get us far in the playoffs. I do believe this little fact is instrumental as to why. It is not everything, there are certainly other factors.

Like a bit more of the history. Yes, more Chiefs in a moment, but I simply have to expound a bit more on this Browns-Bengals-Ravens thing, because it is curious.

While Paul Brown was one of the most renowned shapers of the modern NFL game, he did have a reputation as somewhat of an authoritarian. Nothing wrong with being a strong leader, but he had a ruthless grip on power over his franchises. I do know this affected a lot of people adversely, and while I don't know details about all of that, I do know that Brown infamously and quite foolishly refused to hire Bill Walsh in 1975 to coach the Bengals. Walsh very famously and quite brilliantly went on to elevate the San Francisco 49ers to world-class status, winning three Super Bowls in the process including two over the Cincinnati Bengals.

See, I just don't think all of this happens just because. I'm not God, I can't see everything, and I know 98% of folks just think when you go to Vegas and keep rolling everything but sevens every-single-time it's just the breaks. It's just coincidence. It's just luck.

And the Chiefs have just been unlucky time after time after time.

I don't know. Yeah, maybe -- maybe the ball just bounces around goofy against you way more times than not, maybe. But I don't know -- for you see, here's another peculiar thing about the Brown-to-the-Bengals-Browns-to-the-Ravens thing. It is that the present owner of the woebegone Bengals is none other than Mike Brown, the son of Paul Brown.

Ahh, there's that intergenerational thing going there, and yep, I'm telling you, whenever I've seen the Bengals play in the postseason they've kiiinda had that same deer-in-the-headlights play that is so prevalent among Chiefs players every time they're there. I haven't really seen much at all of anything postseason Bengals, I admit, but I did see enough of that 2015 Wild Card Game to see them thoroughly implode. I do know Carson Palmer in his prime had his knee shredded in another earlier playoff game against Pittsburgh that pretty much ruined their hopes to win (and certainly a lot more beyond that).

Talk to a Bengals fan, I'd venture to say the things they say about postseason stuff wouldn't be much different than what Chiefs fans would say.

Except that another factor is the way they lose. I really don't know a whole lot about those Bengals postseason games, and I do know a lot about the Chiefs ones. In their recent playoff games decided by seven points or fewer, the Chiefs have lost the last seven in a row, often in the most horrific ways imaginable. The average score of those last seven playoff games the Bengals have consecutively lost was 25.1-12.9.  I just don't see the reality of much in-game heartbreak there like the Chiefs Kingdom has had to suffer.

And yet another kind of goofy thing -- there are so many! -- of all the teams present in the AFC at the merger in 1970 (meaning excluding the Jaguars, the Texans, and the present version of the Browns) the Chiefs have played every one of them in the playoffs -- and, by the way, lost to every one of them at least once -- except, get this, the Bengals.

One more incidental note before concluding this post with the Chiefs, just another kind of interesting thing. The last Bengals regular season game of this year was against the Ravens -- remember the Ravens (formerly the Browns) have had a number of years of winning at least one playoff game that is over twice as long as the Bengals have had in less than half the time of existence in the league.

So here is the final game, Bengals at Ravens. Bengals are already out of the playoff picture, but the Ravens simply need a home win against the 6-9 Bengals to make the playoffs -- ironically Baltimore's first game the next week would've been against the Chiefs! Baltimore was ahead 27-24 with under a minute left and the Bengals facing 4th down and long at mid-field. They just needed this stop, game over, the Ravens go to the playoffs. The fans were on their feet effusively anticipating a raucous celebration!

Bengals QB Andy Dalton then fires a strike between five Ravens defenders to Tyler Boyd who sprints past them all for the touchdown, stunning Ravens fans everywhere. How delicious was that. Of course right after that the Chiefs were allowed to face a much weaker Titans team in that first playoff game, and the Titans still won.

So we finish here with that Bengals-Chiefs comparison, with the proving the hypothesis. One could say the Bengals have had it worse, winning percentage wise. But the hypothesis is essentially this.

The Chiefs have the most ridiculously abominable record when it comes to being a winning team in the regular season, then suddenly finding ways to inexplicably lose in the postseason.

And by that measure, the Chiefs "win" hands-down.

The Bengals have not had a very good team, ever, in the regular season. Their percentage is .457, ranking mid-pack among teams with losing records for the total franchise (by the way the worst is Tampa Bay at .358). For most of their history they have simply not made the playoffs at all. They've not been terrible, just not consistently very good.

Three times they've gone 12-4 , the best record they've ever had, and twice went to the Super Bowl on that record. Most of their playoff losses have come in the past several years when they have indeed been very good yet done the very familiar Chiefs thing and just tanked in the first postseason game played.

But even those numbers simply don't match up with the number of times the Chiefs have dominated the regular season and then...

Ick.

Fast forward to today, 2018, a new era of Chiefs football starts right now. We do know that things do genuinely look very promising for the Chiefs. Who wants to hear about past disconsolations -- I can understand why you'd have stopped reading this post about 1/20th of the way through, I understand. I'm hearing right now Brett Veach is making moves and shaking things up that reflect a commitment to keep the winning going, and everyone is thoroughly excited about Pat Mahomes taking the reigns and seeing what he can do to not only win regular season games but -- could-it-be -- postseason games. I'm open and willing and eager to see it happen.

And Clark?

Well, there're more thoughts on all of this to come in future posts in this series -- stay tuned!
__

(Episode III)
___